Getting to Yes Isn’t the Same as Getting It Right
A client believes they have found the right person.
The candidate is not so sure.
Maybe the compensation does not match the responsibility. Maybe the candidate sees the role differently after meeting the leadership team. Maybe the client expects someone to arrive ready to solve problems the candidate believes will require more authority, resources, or time.
At that point, recruiting can become a negotiation.
How do we get the candidate comfortable enough to say yes?
But that is not necessarily what it means to win the seat.
An Acceptance Is Not the Same as Alignment
There is an obvious short-term definition of success in recruiting: the position gets filled.
The client gets a start date. The candidate signs the offer. The search closes.
But if both sides entered that agreement with different expectations, the disagreement did not disappear. It simply moved past the recruiting process and into the first few months of employment.
That can show up quickly.
The client thinks the new hire is moving too slowly.
The candidate discovers they do not have the authority they expected.
Responsibilities expand beyond what was discussed.
The organization believes certain outcomes should already be visible while the new hire is still trying to understand the business.
Technically, the seat was filled.
It was never really won.
.jpg)
Disagreement Is Useful Information
A good recruiter should not automatically treat disagreement as resistance that needs to be overcome.
Sometimes it is evidence.
If a candidate pushes back on compensation, scope, expectations, reporting structure, or decision-making authority, the question is not simply how to get past the objection.
The question is what that objection tells us about the role.
The same applies when a client begins questioning whether a strong candidate has enough industry experience, the right title, or the exact background originally requested.
Those moments force everyone to get more specific.
What does this person actually need to accomplish?
What authority will they have?
Which capabilities are essential on day one?
What can reasonably be learned?
What would make this hire successful 12 months from now?
When those answers are clear, disagreement becomes easier to evaluate.
The Choice Reveals the Hiring Identity
This is where a search can reveal something about the organization behind it.
Under pressure to fill the position, does the company try to sell the candidate harder?
Does it quietly change expectations to get the offer accepted?
Does it dismiss legitimate candidate concerns because the résumé looks too good to lose?
Or does it use the disagreement to test whether both sides are actually committing to the same outcome?
Candidates are making a similar choice.
Are they pursuing the title, compensation, or opportunity despite unresolved concerns? Or are they evaluating whether the environment will allow them to succeed once they arrive?
Winning the seat requires both sides to understand what they are agreeing to.
That may lead to an accepted offer.
It may lead to a revised role.
It may even lead to walking away from a candidate who looked perfect on paper.
The goal is not agreement at any cost.
The goal is a client and candidate who can look at the same seat, understand what winning in it requires, and still choose each other.
That is a placement worth making.
Looking for more insight in recruiting? Subscribe to our newsletter today.
.jpg)






